Safety & OperationsClearance sheet

NTSB finds Forest Service approval allowed corrosion in two aircraft

NTSB found Forest Service approval tests missed corrosion risks in two trial aircraft, damaging an MD-87 wing spar, more than 90 connectors and three engines.

Read-back

  1. NTSB’s November 17, 2026 action followed corrosion in two aircraft during the 2023 FR-200 trial.
  2. FR-200 received full Forest Service approval in December 2022 before entering the 2023 trial.
  3. Corrosion penetrated more than half the thickness of an MD-87 wing-spar doubler.
  4. Aero Air replaced more than 90 connectors, several control cables and a 44-inch fuselage section; three engines also corroded.
  5. The Forest Service suspended FR-100 and FR-200 qualifications in May 2024 and removed both in December 2024.
Fire retardant caused corrosion in firefighting aircraft, NTSB finds
PlateFire retardant caused corrosion in firefighting aircraft, NTSB finds — TeeFarm / pixabay

By Grace Kim

Corrosion penetrated more than half the thickness of an MD-87 wing-spar doubler during a 2023 U.S. Forest Service trial of Fortress FR-200, according to a National Transportation Safety Board investigation that called for tougher testing on November 17, 2026. The damage turned a chemical-compatibility question into structural repair across two aircraft, although the investigation did not establish a nationwide failure rate.

The NTSB examined a BAe 146-200A operated by Montana-based Neptune Aviation Services and an MD-87 operated by Oregon-based Aero Air, which flies firefighting missions as Erickson Aero Tanker. On the MD-87, corrosion reached a wing-spar doubler, the reinforcement forming part of the wing’s main load-bearing structure.

Aero Air replaced more than 90 electrical connectors, several control cables and an approximately 44-inch (3-foot-8-inch) section of a lengthwise fuselage structural member. Investigators found corrosion in three engines used on the twin-engine aircraft at different times during the trial.

The BAe 146-200A showed significant corrosion inside its retardant tank after postseason maintenance. The NTSB account gave no repair bill, availability period or fleet count beyond the two trial aircraft.

What did the 2023 trial expose?

Both aircraft joined a 2023 Forest Service trial designed to examine how newly approved FR-200 could be used alongside an existing product. Fortress North America manufactured FR-200, which used magnesium chloride as its active retardant salt. Later in the season, the aircraft alternated between FR-200 and Phos-Chek MVP-Fx, a phosphate-based product made by Perimeter Solutions.

The trial did not require aircraft to wash retardant tanks between product loads, so residual chemicals could mix. Subsequent testing showed FR-200 could promote corrosion on its own, while mixing it with a phosphate-based retardant could intensify corrosion under some conditions. The result exposed the gap between laboratory approval and the operating sequence.

Why did FR-200 qualify despite earlier warnings?

The Forest Service granted FR-200 full approval in December 2022 after laboratory tests and a field evaluation using a single-engine airtanker with a fiberglass retardant tank. Those qualification tests examined individual metal samples but did not adequately represent the combinations of metals, fasteners, joints and assembled structures found in aircraft. The laboratory covered samples; assembled aircraft supplied the evidence.

Warnings had arrived earlier. A 2021 evaluation of Fortress FR-100, a related magnesium-chloride-based product, produced operator reports of corrosion and deposits when it interacted with existing retardants, and laboratory testing subsequently confirmed incompatibilities.

NTSB investigators said operator and vendor feedback showed a need for further testing and revised procedures. The Forest Service nevertheless began the 2023 trial without additional corrosion testing.

What changed after the corrosion findings?

Postseason maintenance revealed the damage. The Forest Service notified the NTSB in March 2024 and requested an investigation because corrosion could lead to an accident. The agency suspended FR-100 and FR-200 qualifications in May 2024, then removed both products from its approved list in December 2024.

The NTSB said withdrawing FR-200 and FR-100 “did not address the shortcomings in the testing process that allowed them to be approved.” That distinction leaves the product decision and the system decision in different places.

Compass Minerals, Fortress’s parent, acknowledged the corrosion findings in March 2024, saying: “Safety took priority” and the products “had passed the Forest Service’s prescribed tests.” In March 2025, the company announced plans to wind down Fortress North America as part of a broader cost-cutting program.

What must change in Forest Service approval?

On November 17, 2026, the NTSB called for stronger U.S. Forest Service testing requirements. It wants the agency to work with aircraft corrosion specialists, operators and manufacturers to develop tests that better represent aircraft construction and the effects of mixing retardants. It also recommended adding those tests to the agency’s qualification requirements.

FR-200 entered the 2023 trial with full Forest Service approval, granted in December 2022. The November 2026 NTSB action produced recommendations, not an amended qualification rule. The report identifies FR-200 alone, and its mixture with Perimeter Solutions’ Phos-Chek MVP-Fx, as corrosion risks; it does not say the phosphate product causes corrosion independently.

At network level, Forest Service approval governs use on U.S. firefighting aircraft, so the testing gap reaches beyond the two trial airframes. The report gives no national fleet count, so it cannot support a claim that corrosion affected the wider fleet at the observed rate.

Operationally, the measurable burden was replacement of structural, electrical and engine components; the NTSB published neither repair costs nor aircraft downtime. The next regulatory milestone is assembly-level and mixed-retardant testing inside the Forest Service’s qualification requirements. Without that, product approval remains better documented at sample scale than at aircraft scale.

via AeroTime (Source)

Filed under

  • aircraft-corrosion
  • ntsb
  • fr-200
  • forest-service
  • forest-firefighting
Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Commercial aviation industry coverage at Flightdeck Report.

692 articles

Same bay

« Previous articleNext article »