Airspace & RegulationClearance sheet

Private ANSPs form APANSO to force tendering of European tower services

APANSO, founded by Skyway and ACR, wants EU rules to force tenders of terminal ATC services and mandatory airport-ANSP service level agreements from RP5.

Read-back

  1. APANSO launched this month with two founding members, Skyway and ACR, chaired by Raquel Martínez Arnáiz.
  2. Seven Swiss regional airports cost taxpayers 35 million Swiss francs a year in recurring ANS charges.
  3. APANSO wants the 2024 regulation changed so member states must, not may, tender terminal ANS services.
  4. A formal industry launch is planned for 2027.
  5. Air Navigation Solutions was excluded because DFS is a shareholder.
Private air traffic management, ATM competition, the European Union and APANSO
PlatePrivate air traffic management, ATM competition, the European Union and APANSO — WayneJackson / pixabay

Seven regional airports in Switzerland cost the taxpayer 35 million Swiss francs a year in recurring air navigation charges, a figure APANSO's new chairwoman calls "way beyond any kind of benchmark". That number is the recruiting poster for APANSO, the non-profit association launched earlier this month to represent privately owned air navigation service providers, mainly inside the European Union.

Raquel Martínez Arnáiz chairs the organisation, which was founded by two private ANSPs: Skyway and ACR. The pair began talking about a year ago. "Even though we were in different countries with different environments we had the same barriers and problems," she told Philip Butterworth-Hayes in an interview. The barriers, she argues, are institutional and political rather than operational, because private providers compete against sovereign monopolies that face no re-tender and no penalty regime.

What conditions set private ANSPs apart?

Private providers work under contract with airport operators. If staffing problems keep an airport from opening on time, or agreed demand levels are not met, the provider pays a penalty. Each contract ends in a new tender, at which the incumbent must prove its offer beats the alternatives. Martínez Arnáiz puts the safety argument bluntly: for APANSO members safety is "literally existential", in a way it is not for providers in a sovereign monopoly position.

What does APANSO want changed?

The association's first white paper targets terminal air traffic services, and its central demand concerns the 2024 European regulation. Member states currently "may" tender terminal ANS; APANSO wants that word changed to "must", leaving states free to pick a state-owned or private winner. Its accompanying proposals, aimed at the RP5 reference period, include:

  • A mandatory service level agreement between every airport and its ANSP, absent today in most cases.
  • A single SLA indicator combining service cost with the cost of delays, so quality is measured alongside price.
  • Consequences, yet to be specified, for persistent under-performance.

Where does it draw the membership line?

The scope is wider than towers. APANSO intends to cover training, meteorological services and CNS, with interest from a digital AIM company; drone-sector firms are welcome in principle, though the founders worry the group could drift into becoming a drone industry body. The definition of a private ANS company is strict: separate accounting from any regulated state aid. Air Navigation Solutions in the UK, formerly at Gatwick and now at Edinburgh, expressed interest but fails the test, because DFS holds a shareholding.

Is the politics moving their way?

The evidence is mixed but trending in their favour. The revised Single European Sky framework regulation now explicitly introduces terminal-area ANS provision under micro market conditions, a tool member states can use but were never obliged to deploy. Martínez Arnáiz says the European Commission, which APANSO met before launching, is convinced this is the way forward. Spain's ministry backs a competitive environment for airport ANS, as do Sweden and Switzerland, and she claims no opposition has emerged in states that have tried competition.

En-route may remain a natural monopoly, she concedes, since duplicating infrastructure makes little sense. Training, CNS, terminal ANS and UTM, in her view, have nothing to do with monopoly at all.

A formal industry launch is pencilled in for 2027, with membership numbers still undefined while the founders sift interest generated by last week's publications. Airlines have not yet been contacted, nor have controllers, though talks with both are planned. On automation, Martínez Arnáiz is restrained: she does not see a fully digital autonomous system controlling Europe's skies in the near or even mid-term future. APANSO's immediate task is narrower and harder — converting a permissive clause into an obligation, one member state at a time.

via unmannedairspace.info (Source)

Filed under

  • apanso
  • air-navigation-services
  • single-european-sky
  • competitive-tendering
  • air-traffic-control
Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Commercial aviation industry coverage at Flightdeck Report.

692 articles

Same bay

« Previous articleNext article »