Airspace & RegulationClearance sheet

Air New Zealand faces charges over passenger compensation guidance

ComCom will charge Air New Zealand over compensation guidance for controllable disruptions, while the airline says a 62,000-plus claim review found mistakes in fewer than 1% of cases.

Air New Zealand accused of misleading consumers on compensation
PlateAir New Zealand accused of misleading consumers on compensation — AI-generated

By James Calloway

The Commerce Commission will file charges against Air New Zealand in Auckland District Court over compensation statements that it believes misled consumers since January 2024, for flights disrupted for reasons within the airline’s control.

ComCom, New Zealand’s equivalent of Australia’s Competition and Consumer Commission, alleges Air New Zealand described compensation as strictly capped below statutory limits and restricted liability for certain reimbursements. The charges will proceed under the Fair Trading Act.

Deputy chair Anne Callinan said passengers “missed out on money they were entitled to under the law.” According to ComCom, some believed they had no entitlement, while the airline rejected legitimate reimbursement claims.

What changes for passengers after disruptions within airline control?

Callinan said New Zealand’s Civil Aviation Act requires airlines to reimburse domestic passengers for losses caused by cancellations or delays within airline control. She cited staffing and mechanical issues as examples.

  • Reimbursement of reasonable meals, accommodation and other costs caused by the delay.
  • A limit of up to 10 times the cost of the ticket for domestic claims.

International passengers have a separate route. The Montreal Convention provides reimbursement for delay- and cancellation-related costs up to convention limits, unless the airline took all reasonable steps to prevent the disruption.

Callinan said consumers had raised concerns about Air New Zealand frequently over the past five years. ComCom would act, she said, wherever it believed a business had failed to honor legal entitlements or misled consumers.

Air New Zealand reviewed more than 62,000 claims

Chief customer and digital officer Jeremy O’Brien said Air New Zealand approached the investigation in good faith and with a genuine commitment to customers. He acknowledged concerns about a small number of cases where communications were unclear or compensation policies were not applied as intended.

He said: “We acknowledge that we didn’t get it right for those customers, and we’re sorry.” The airline’s voluntary review covered more than 62,000 claims involving circumstances within its control.

Air New Zealand found mistakes in fewer than 1% of cases and proactively contacted those customers to put the matters right. The airline said the mistakes were neither intentional nor systemic. It quickly reinforced compensation guidance and staff training to communicate entitlements more clearly and consistently.

O’Brien said he was disappointed that ComCom had chosen proceedings despite Air New Zealand’s actions. The airline would respect the Commission’s role and cooperate throughout the process.

The airline also said it carried nearly 45 million passengers over the same period. That total measures traffic, not compensation entitlement. Neither side has disclosed how many passengers encountered controllable disruption, submitted eligible claims or received reimbursement.

Thus, the less-than-1% result cannot establish the prevalence of misstatements across all disrupted journeys. The figures provided do not specify the review period or the amount spent on corrections.

Jetstar penalty sets the financial context

ComCom previously secured a record NZ$2.25 million fine against Jetstar for misleading customers about flight compensation. Jetstar received sentences on 20 charges of breaching the Fair Trading Act in 2022 and 2023. It had faced a potential fine of around NZ$2.5 million, with a 25 per cent uplift based on its size and financial position.

That penalty shows the financial exposure of misleading compensation guidance. It does not determine Air New Zealand’s liability.

Neither ComCom nor Air New Zealand has disclosed a penalty demand, total reimbursement figure, affected-passenger count or hearing date.

Costs, claims and network effects

The dispute does not concern a fleet decision, route cancellation or capacity reduction. It concerns compensation language and claims handling after disruption, rather than Air New Zealand’s operating schedule.

For the airline, exposure includes reimbursement obligations, compliance work, staff training, legal defense and any penalty imposed by the court. For customers, clearer statements should reduce mistaken decisions about claiming meals or hotels after airline-controlled delays.

ComCom’s stated legal position offers the practical starting point, not a court ruling. The filing creates no finding that every challenged claim was valid, nor does the airline’s review establish that every communication was lawful.

Until Auckland District Court tests the evidence, ComCom’s allegations remain unproven, and Air New Zealand’s under-1% finding remains the airline’s own account. The next phase should establish whether disputed statements and rejected claims breached the Fair Trading Act, and what that means for compensation already paid or still sought.

via australianaviation.com.au (Source)

Filed under

  • air-new-zealand
  • passenger-compensation
  • new-zealand-commerce-commission
  • consumer-protection
  • fair-trading-act
Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Commercial aviation industry coverage at Flightdeck Report.

726 articles

Same bay

« Previous articleNext article »