Clearance CLR-7389 · SAF196
SAFLEA
Safety & OperationsClearance sheet
Learjet 60 Broke Up at Altitude Before Fatal Florida Crash
NTSB found left elevator pieces up to 3.8 miles from the Palm Beach crash site. ATC audio shows the Learjet 60 lost 22,000 ft after entering a thunderstorm, killing all nine aboard.
Read-back
- Nine people died when a Learjet 60 crashed near West Palm Beach, Florida, on Nov. 1 after flying into a thunderstorm.
- NTSB member Tom Chapman said three pieces of the left elevator were found 1.3 to 3.8 miles from the crash site in Greenacres.
- ATC audio shows the jet descended at up to 22,000 feet per minute and banked 60 degrees after reporting ice and moderate turbulence at 35,000 feet.
- Co-pilot Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, 20, declared a mayday about 15 seconds after a climb to 37,000 feet was approved.
- Bombardier said it cannot comment on causes until the ICAO Annex 13 investigation is complete.

A Learjet 60 lost elevator pieces over as much as 2.5 miles of Florida suburbs before it crashed near West Palm Beach on Nov. 1, killing all nine people on board. National Transportation Safety Board member Tom Chapman said Tuesday that three sections of the left elevator — the tail surface that controls pitch — were found scattered 1.3 to 3.8 miles from the impact site in Greenacres.
The aircraft, operated privately and captained by 55-year-old Jeffrey Gregory, was flying from Texas to Freeport in the Bahamas with seven passengers and 20-year-old co-pilot Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras of Boca Raton at the radios. Newly released air traffic control recordings show the crew flew into a large thunderstorm over South Florida and lost control within roughly two minutes of their first weather report to controllers.
What does the audio actually show?
At about 12:47 p.m., Filgueiras checked in with Miami Air Route Traffic Control Center in a calm, routine tone. "We have light, clear ice that is manageable and moderate turbulence," she reported while turning direct to Freeport.
The controller asked her to repeat the conditions, then offered assistance. Filgueiras asked whether "better rides" — smoother air, in controller shorthand — were available ahead. "The rides do improve in my airspace. You're kind of far outside of it right now, and you can expect better rides ahead," the controller responded.
Minutes later the situation unraveled. The crew reported picking up precipitation and requested a climb from 35,000 to 37,000 feet. Controllers approved it. About 15 seconds after that approval, Filgueiras issued a mayday: "We're descending 8,000 — mayday, mayday — we're descending 10,000 feet per minute."
She returned seconds later with a declared emergency and worsening numbers: "We are in an overspeed condition descending 20,000 feet per minute." Then: "We are descending 22,000 feet, and we are banking 60 degrees." Her final transmission was "We're out of time." Controllers could not re-establish contact.
Was it the weather, the aircraft, or the decisions?
Independent pilots who reviewed the sequence point in different directions. Michael Henderson, who runs California-based Legal Eagles Aviation and a flight school, questioned why the Learjet was not diverted around the storm when other crews that day could be heard coordinating weather deviations with controllers.
"It's the weather that destroyed the plane," Henderson said. "The question is why did they fly into it."
He also flagged a known handling characteristic of the type. The Learjet 60, he said, can stall in challenging weather when airflow over the wings approaches the speed of sound, and in turbulence that airflow can push the nose down in a phenomenon called Mach tuck. Henderson added that he was "really tired" of reflexive pilot-error conclusions: "There's more behind this than weather."
Based on where the elevator debris landed, Henderson estimated the surface separated at about 22,000 feet, which would explain the 60-degree bank heard in the final transmissions.
David Evans, an Airline Transport Pilot certificate holder who runs Arizona-based Hi-Per Aviation, framed the timeline more starkly. Icing plus turbulence can leave a crew with seconds to recover. "By the time they had it all figured out, they lost control of the aircraft," he said. "They lost control so much it was nonrecoverable."
Keith Cianfrani, a retired military and commercial pilot at Florida-based Aviation Safety Consultants, noted that either mechanism fits the wreckage pattern. Icing disturbs airflow over the wing and can induce a stall, while rough air inside a thunderstorm can rip an airframe apart outright.
The investigation ahead
Bombardier, which manufactured the Learjet 60, said in a statement it is "deeply saddened by this tragic event" and extended sympathies to those affected. Citing Annex 13 to the Convention on International Civil Aviation, the company said it cannot comment on potential causes until the investigation is complete.
The NTSB is investigating. Cianfrani outlined the question investigators will have to answer: "We don't just look at weather. We look at the decisions leading up to it."
Filgueiras' father, Allan Filgueiras, a licensed private pilot who helped teach his daughter to fly, said he has listened to the full ATC recording many times. "Trying to find a clue in my head how that happened," he said. "I wanted to be by her side, to help her."
The final NTSB report will have to weigh storm penetration, in-flight icing, and possible structural failure together — and determine which came first.
via miamiherald.com (Original)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Commercial aviation industry coverage at Flightdeck Report.
673 articles
Same bay
- FDR533NTSB Finds Learjet Elevator Pieces Miles From Florida Crash Site · November 6, 2026
- FDR334Learjet Crew Called Mayday 30 Seconds After Icing Report · November 5, 2026
- FDR576NTSB Finds Learjet 60 Elevator Pieces Miles From Florida Crash Site · November 5, 2026
- FDR262Nine Killed as Learjet 60 Dives Into Palm Beach County Neighborhood · November 2, 2026
- FDR772Nine Dead as Learjet 60 Lost With Icing Report Over Florida · November 2, 2026